Smith’s Homemade

super cute ice cream shop, ice cream flavors are all yummy and unique. My strawberry milkshake was perfectly blended and priced well. The workers are always friendly and atmosphere is very organized and clean, decor is adorable

The first time I came I got a banana split in a cup and I got vanilla ice cream, bananas obviously, strawberries, pineapples, and hot fudge. It was absolutely delicious and the price was beautiful! I also got two pup cups! Definitely wanted to come back! The second time I came I ordered the same thing except for the pup cups. However my banana split came with one of the white plastic spoonfuls of Smucker’s pineapples, but the pineapples were only placed on top of the whipped cream. I had about 3/4 of a diced up strawberry and some hot fudge drizzled around the walls of the cup. The price was different the second time as well. The first time I paid about $7 for the banana split and $2 for each of the pup cups and I left a tip and the total of everything was $14. This time my total came to 10 something but the banana split was completely different and I didn’t get the pup cups. Also, it rang up as $6.77 and I had to do a second transaction for $3 and some change. I’m not sure why because the first time the quality was top tier and less expensive and this time the quality was definitely not top tier and much more expensive. It tasted good but definitely not what I was expecting. The girl working there was absolutely delightful and I am not complaining about her in any way! She was very kind and very sweet and she was just doing her job. However I do think that there should be uniform recipes for things and uniform prices. I was disappointed this time around and I’m not sure if I will want to come back because I don’t want to risk paying $10 for a subpar banana split. Especially when it was much better the first time around and the price wasn’t as bad. Again, the girl working this evening was absolutely awesome and I wish nothing but the best for her and her future. She was such a sweet girl and I don’t believe she was doing anything intentionally wrong. I think they have really good ice cream and everyone I’ve encountered there is very sweet, but I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t disappointed this time. I was also confused as to why the price ring up to $6.77 and I then had to do a separate transaction and pay more money than I did the first time. If this sounds confusing, I agree because I’m confused as well. Anyway I hope this helps and if you go I’m sure you will enjoy your experience as well as your sweets! Hopefully the kinks can get worked out.

Great little mom and pops ice cream store. Place was very neat and clean. Staff was friendly and welcoming. Family got 3 different flavors and they where all very good. Have no problem coming back to try more.